IN A LONELY PLACE (1950): A FILM REVIEW AND A DEVOTIONAL REFLECTION
Lovers live across a courtyard from each other, and though they never move in together, they become co-dependent, nonetheless. Bogart expresses his cool demeanor when he says, “You know, Miss Gray, you are one up on me. You can see into my apartment, but I can’t see into yours.” “I promise you,” she replies, “I won’t take advantage of it.” And we had to know the response that was coming: “I would, if it were the other way around.” Classic cool. Classic Bogie. But in this one, it’s only one part of a portrait that gets more dim as the movie goes on.
“In a Lonely Place” (1950) is a film full of rich symbolism and deep emotional involvement, not only between the characters, but between the film itself and its audience. The one and only Humphrey Bogart plays Dixon Steele, who lives in an apartment opposite Laurel Gray (Gloria Grahame). The two are separated by a courtyard, in ways as transcendent in meaning as the one found in Alfred Hitchcock’s “Rear Window” (1954). It is a metaphor for the distance between them, as well as the closeness. “So close, yet so far away,” as they say.
Steele is a very troubled man. Bogart, contrary to what many seem to think of him, could play a vulnerable man just as convincingly as he could a tough guy. The greatest film ever made, “Casablanca” (1942), which came out about a decade before this one, showed two sides of his talent in one character. He was the cynical man who “sticks his neck out for no one,” but who also cries alone at night, getting drunk and sad over a song because he is so in love. “In a Lonely Place” is a classic film, and one reason is because of the complexity of Bogart’s character.
Why is Dixon Steele so troubled? One problem is he drinks too much. He is what we would call a functioning alcoholic. Some have said the same was true of Bogart in real life. He definitely drank too much, there’s no question about that. Here he plays a Hollywood screenwriter of some renown going through the worst writer’s block of his career. And his temperament, his mental state, is not stable enough for him to be able to handle that kind of adversity at this point in his life.
At the time of the film’s release, few seemed to recognize the brilliance of Bogart’s performance. But time has brought forth the realization that his portrayal of Dixon Steele is one of his finest performances. Here is a character who is extremely artistic, but given to bursts of violence because of his horrible temper. He was also capable of amazing compassion and quickly felt shame when he allowed his emotions to get the best of him. Much has been written by those who knew the real Bogart about how this character was the most like the real man of any he ever played. Even his wife Lauren Bacall admitted that at times his temper frightened her, though he evidently never crossed the line of danger. Bogart, in other words, was a very complex man, just as Steele is.
Nicholas Ray, whose expert direction is a tremendous reason for the film’s greatness, commented that the title, “In a Lonely Place,” was a perfect expression of the price Bogart paid for superstardom. He was isolated in his own way, a man who was stubborn and whose vices were extremely unhealthy. Yet he was such a talent, such a great actor, that Ray found him easy to direct.
The film was a personal venture for Bogart, produced by his own Santana Productions company. The first film by Santana was the previous year’s “Knock on Any Door” (1949), which starred Bogart and was also directed by Ray. Perhaps the independent nature of the project contributed to its quality and Bogart’s first-class performance. This is a master at his craft in top form. There is some controversy about exactly how much revision was done to Andrew Solt’s script. Some versions of the story have Bogart completely satisfied with the original draft, and therefore few changes were made. Those close to Ray, however, suggested that changes were made almost every day of filming. However it came about, it worked wonderfully.
The screenplay was based on Edmund H. North’s adaptation of Dorothy B. Hughes’s 1947 novel. That novel is a noir classic, and Bogart’s production values ensure that the story makes logical sense while also dragging us, kicking and screaming, into a world of complex trouble, personifying the storms of life. This is not about good versus evil. It is about strength and weakness tied up in its adult players. Steele is like a wave of the sea, driven and tossed by the wind. He has no place to stand because he has lost all of his confidence. And there is a woman here who should have known better than to become involved with a man like him.
Laurel is his neighbor and feels a connection to him that is hard to understand. She’s an aspiring actress, so that part is easy to see. But she also seems to understand more about Steele than he does about himself. She is beautiful and brilliant and exactly what he needs, if he could only keep his demons under control enough to appreciate her. We sense that she is drawn to him partly because he is broken and needs fixing, and that gives her nurturing side an outlet. But the film is a cautionary tale to women who think they can change troubled and dangerous men. It is always better to stay away from someone who has no control over their emotions and whose mental issues cause them to be self-absorbed.
Bogart played opposite many outstanding actresses in his career. Lauren Bacall, of course, was the best, making four films with him, all of them classics. She was wanted for the role of Laurel Gray and would have been an excellent choice—the part would have suited her perfectly—considering the chemistry the two had onscreen numerous times and the fact that they were married in real life. They were also extremely popular together and their pairing would have ensured the financial success of the film. The problem was Bogart’s formation of his own production company. The executives at Warner Bros. resented that, fearing that it was a dangerous step in the direction of taking away from the importance of the major studios. They refused to allow Bacall to make the film and most believe it was a form of punishment for Bogie’s insurrection against the system.
Ginger Rogers was also considered, but Ray fought to have his wife, Gloria Grahame, cast. It was evidently a strictly professional decision, though, because their marriage was on its last legs. They would be divorced within a few years and were separated even then, but it turned out to be a brilliant move. Grahame, who many recognize from the Christmas classic “It’s a Wonderful Life” (1946), is phenomenal as Laurel Gray. Bogart is clearly at ease with her and their romance works powerfully. She was lovely and extremely talented. Most critics agree—and I agree—that “In a Lonely Place” is her greatest performance.
This is one of the most gut-wrenching and heartbreaking love stories ever told. It is a classic film noir, one of the greatest ever made. Bogart practically defined the genre, and everything about this film fits into it. There is anger, unpredictability, murder, and enough emotional weight to fill a shelf of tragedies. But at its core, “In a Lonely Place” is about a man who is his own worst enemy and a woman who becomes hers, solely by virtue of loving a man whom she cannot help, no matter how hard she tries.
And that truth carries a quiet devotional lesson.
Dixon Steele is not destroyed by the world around him nearly as much as he is by the storms within him. His temper, his pride, his addictions, and his wounded soul slowly poison the love that might have saved him. The tragedy of the story is that he cannot overcome himself.
In that sense, the film becomes an unexpected mirror of the human condition. The Bible reminds us that the deepest struggles of life rise from within the heart. Left to ourselves, we are often like waves of the sea, driven and tossed by the wind, unable to stand firmly because our own weaknesses undo us.
But where the film leaves us in tragedy, the gospel offers hope.
The Lord Jesus Christ came to do what broken men like Dixon Steele cannot do for themselves. He brings peace to the restless heart, forgiveness to the guilty conscience, and a new life to those who surrender their storms to Him. The human soul does not have to remain in a lonely place forever.
And this is where the hope of Christ shines brightest. Jesus does not merely observe our loneliness; He enters it. The Son of God stepped into the broken world of human sorrow, rejection, and isolation so that no soul would have to remain trapped there forever. The Bible says that He was a man acquainted with grief and sorrow, one who knew what it meant to be misunderstood and abandoned. Yet through His cross and resurrection He opened a path out of that lonely place.
When a person turns to Him in faith, the distance between God and the soul is closed, the guilt that isolates us is forgiven, and the restless heart finally finds its home. Christ does what no human love, no success, and no talent can accomplish—He brings us into fellowship with God and gives us a peace that steadies the soul, so that we are no longer wandering through life alone.
That is something even the darkest film noir cannot take away.
_____________
Lord Jesus, You know the storms that rage inside every human heart. Save us from the pride, anger, and brokenness that can destroy our lives and the lives of those we love. Give us new hearts, steady minds, and the peace that only You can give. Amen.
BDD
