There’s a new GOAT when it comes to playing Ebenezer Scrooge.
For years, I considered Albert Finney and George C. Scott the gold standards in portraying Charles Dickens’s unforgettable character. Both performances were magnificent, and I never imagined anyone would surpass them. But having recently watched Ebenezer, I have to say it: Johnny Depp’s performance has to be seen to be believed.
And I’m not easily impressed when it comes to A Christmas Carol. I’m a fan of fans. I’ve loved this story for years, watched countless adaptations, and returned to Dickens’s original work with enormous pleasure.
In many ways, I am living this story. So it’s even more meaningful now than it has been in the past.
This new film is something special.
A word of caution: I wouldn’t recommend it for small children. It’s dark. There are moments when the atmosphere approaches Gothic horror, but that is entirely appropriate. After all, Dickens wrote a ghost story! Beneath the Christmas decorations, cheerful gatherings, and sentimental memories, A Christmas Carol has always contained some genuinely frightening material.
The filmmakers understand that.
They also understand something else. If we’re going to continue producing adaptations of a story that has been told and retold for generations, we must occasionally explore its characters more deeply, develop certain elements, and discover fresh ways of presenting familiar material.
This film doesn’t attempt to become another version of the Finney or Scott classics. It establishes an identity of its own. Some liberties are taken, certainly, but the essential spirit of Dickens survives beautifully.
Director Ti West, screenwriter Nathaniel Halpern, and an extraordinary cast featuring Depp, Ian McKellen, Rupert Grint, Andrea Riseborough, Sam Claflin, Daisy Ridley, and Tramell Tillman clearly understood the assignment.
Ttelling A Christmas Carol in a meaningful and powerful way requires more than spectacular scenery, frightening ghosts, and Christmas sentimentality. It requires an understanding of the human heart. They have given us something atmospheric, imaginative, unsettling, and ultimately uplifting. The darkness must be convincing if the light is going to be glorious. Above all, they understood that this is not merely a story about a miserable old miser encountering three spirits. It is a story about redemption, second chances, and the extraordinary power of change.
I loved it.
The experience inspired me to return to the original novella and read it again. What a remarkable little masterpiece. Dickens could make a sentence dance, a character breathe, and a moral truth emerge without turning his story into a lecture.
And the truth struck me with renewed force.
People can change.
Ebenezer Scrooge was not merely having a bad day. He had spent years constructing a miserable existence. His greed had hardened into habit. His loneliness had become a way of life. His contempt for others had developed into something resembling a philosophy.
He was a prisoner, but the prison was largely of his own making.
And then something extraordinary happened.
He changed.
Not his circumstances. Not his financial position. Not his surroundings.
He changed.
The same man who resented Christmas began celebrating it. The man who dismissed the suffering of others became generous. He who had shut himself off from human affection discovered the joy of loving people.
What makes this so powerful is that Scrooge’s past remained unchanged. The years he had wasted were still wasted. The mistakes he had made were still real. But his past no longer had to dictate his future.
What a lesson here for every one of us.
Perhaps we’ve become cynical. Allowed disappointment to make us bitter. Maybe we’ve neglected relationships and developed destructive habits and settled into patterns of behavior that ought to have changed years ago.
Well, why not change them now?
Why wait for another Christmas? Why wait for another year? Why wait for three ghosts to come knocking?
Let’s go ahead and make changes.
One of the most beautiful truths of the gospel is found in 2 Corinthians 5:17: “Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation; old things have passed away; behold, all things have become new.”
Dickens gave us a marvelous fictional picture of transformation. The gospel offers something infinitely greater: the possibility of a genuinely new life through Jesus Christ.
And perhaps that is why A Christmas Carol never gets old.
The greatest wonder of the story isn’t that Ebenezer Scrooge encountered the supernatural.
It’s that the man who awakened on Christmas morning was not the man who had gone to bed on Christmas Eve.
And if Scrooge could change, perhaps it’s time we considered what needs changing in us.
BDD