How about this for irony: arrogant Calvinists. It is found in hearing a Calvinist speak with absolute certainty about the depravity of humanity while displaying an astonishing confidence in the superiority of his own theological understanding.
According to Calvinistic doctrine, man is so thoroughly corrupted by sin that he cannot even respond to God apart from irresistible divine grace. And yet some of the most outspoken defenders of this system seem remarkably convinced that they alone have properly understood the mysteries of God.
One might reasonably ask: If human nature is so hopelessly corrupted, how did you become so infallible in your interpretation of Scripture?
Of course, Calvinists would answer that spiritual understanding comes through the grace of God. But this introduces another difficulty. If whatever understanding we possess is entirely a gift of grace, what possible grounds could there be for intellectual arrogance?
The Apostle Paul asked, “And what do you have that you did not receive?” (1 Corinthians 4:7).
The question demolishes spiritual pride regardless of one’s theological persuasion.
Consider the remarkable contrast. Calvinism emphasizes the inability of fallen humanity, yet some of its advocates argue as though their theological conclusions are beyond reasonable examination.
They insist upon the limitations of human understanding while speaking as though those limitations mysteriously disappear whenever they interpret Romans 9 or Ephesians 1.
But theological confidence is not the same as theological infallibility. The Bible declares, “Knowledge puffs up, but love edifies” (1 Corinthians 8:1).
The Calvinistic understanding of total depravity should not be confused with the biblical affirmation that all have sinned. Romans 3:23 establishes the universality of sin. It does not establish that sinners are incapable of responding to God’s gracious invitation.
The Bible repeatedly calls human beings to repent, believe, and turn to the Lord. Jesus lamented, “But you are not willing to come to Me that you may have life” (John 5:40).
Notice the language. He identified their unwillingness, not an absolute inability imposed upon them by divine decree.
The issue, however, extends beyond Calvinism. Arrogance is no monopoly of any theological movement. An Arminian, a Baptist, a Methodist, or an independent Christian can become equally intoxicated with the conviction that he has mastered every mystery of divine revelation.
And that is precisely the point.
The moment our theology makes us proud of how humble we are supposed to be, something has gone terribly wrong.
A sound understanding of grace should produce gratitude, not superiority. A recognition of human weakness should inspire patience, not contempt. And a serious study of the Scriptures should make us increasingly conscious of how much remains beyond our comprehension.
The greatest theologian is not necessarily the man who can win the most arguments. He is the man whose understanding of God produces greater reverence, deeper humility, and more Christlike love.
If you read only the New Testament, it would make you nothing but a follower of Jesus. It certainly would not make you a Calvinist.
BDD